top of page

Once Seen, It Cannot Be Unseen: ‘Three Fables, One Human Condition’

9 hours ago
34 min read

Perfume, The Emperor’s New Clothes and West Side Story: A Murderer, an Emperor and a Girl with a Gun is Published


Buy 'Three Fables, One Human Condition, and How to Heal It: Perfume, The Emperor’s New Clothes and West Side Story':



Three Fables, One Human Condition, and How to Heal It
“Consciousness sees the prison. Clarity sees the door. The Pivot touches the handle. Agency opens it. The Crossing begins with the first step outside.”
“I was running for love. I was never running in love.”

A Murderer, an Emperor and a Girl with a Gun

Today I am publishing a book whose claim is so large that it ought really to come with a health warning, and which then sets out to earn that claim with three stories you have known since childhood, or at least since the school play. Three Fables, One Human Condition, and How to Heal It: Perfume, The Emperor’s New Clothes and West Side Story is published today as an eBook from Transformative Life Coach, and its claim is this: the whole of the human condition, and the whole of the way out of it, can be brought into view through three stories that are also fables. Not three hundred. Not a seven-volume system with a glossary and a secret handshake. Three: a dark thriller set in eighteenth-century France, a children’s tale from Copenhagen, and a Broadway musical. I know how that sounds. Stay with me.


Here they are, as the book first tells them. In the first, a child is born on the seventeenth of July 1738 beneath a gutting table at a fish stall in the most stinking corner of Paris, beside the Cemetery of the Innocents. He has the most exquisite nose that has ever existed in a human body, and no smell of his own. Nobody can love him, because nobody can find him. He spends his life learning to manufacture the scent of a lovable human being, out of the young women he murders, and he succeeds so completely that the crowd assembled to watch him die falls into an ecstasy of adoration at the foot of the scaffold. It does not save him. It is what kills him.


In the second, an Emperor who cares for nothing but his wardrobe buys a cloth that is invisible to anybody unfit for his office. He buys it, if you read Andersen closely, not for its beauty but for its use, because it promises him a technology for discovering which of his officials are unfit. Within a week the whole capital is watching itself. Every minister sees nothing and praises everything. The Emperor walks naked through his own city beneath a canopy, the crowd applauds, and a little child says, quite simply, that he has nothing on. The truth passes from mouth to mouth until everybody can say it. And the Emperor, who has felt a shiver run through him because it seemed to him that they were right, holds himself more proudly than ever and walks on, while his chamberlains carry a train that is not there.


In the third, on a playground on the Upper West Side of Manhattan, a young woman kneels over the body of the boy she loves, who has just been shot by a boy from her own side of a war about street corners. She takes the gun from the hand that fired it and turns it on both gangs without distinction. She tells them that they all killed him, that hate was the weapon, and that she has learned enough of it now to kill as well. And then she does not fire. She lowers the gun, and boys from both gangs step forward, uninstructed, and carry him away together.

“The past supplies the gun, the grief, the hatred and the available script. It does not get automatic authorship of the next sentence.”
The cover: three fables behind, a blank page in front, and one pen held in two hands.
The cover: three fables behind, a blank page in front, and one pen held in two hands.

Read as stories, these are a thriller, a fairy tale and a musical. Read as fables, they are one human condition seen from three sides. Perfume is the story everybody longs to inhabit. The Emperor’s New Clothes is the story everybody pretends to believe. West Side Story is the story everybody feels compelled to repeat. And under all three runs the book’s simplest question, which I have come to think is the oldest question in the human condition wearing new clothes of its own: who is holding the pen? In the perfumers’ town of Grasse, conditional lovability holds it. In the Emperor’s city, a collective fiction holds it. On the West Side, an inherited script holds it. The healing, when it comes, does not hand anybody a better story. It returns the pen.


What follows is a tour of the house, conducted by its architect, who has promised to keep his hands off the furniture. I will tell you why these three stories are fables, what they teach about the human condition, how the book says that condition heals, how it keeps its accounts honest, whom it was written for, and where you can find it. I cannot spoil the endings, because you have known them since you were small. What the book hopes to show you is what the endings have known about you all along. Once seen, it cannot be unseen.


Why Fables: The Child Who Arrived Late


Perfume, The Emperor’s New Clothes and West Side Story

A story resolves for you. A paradox refuses to resolve. A parable makes the resolution yours. The book needs the third of these, and it needs something a parable does not always have, which is a body: a story pared down far enough to perform the parable’s operation, while keeping enough flesh on its bones to be loved. That is what I mean by a fable. It lets you be a guest long enough to lower your guard, and then it serves you with papers. The model is very old. In the Second Book of Samuel the prophet Nathan tells King David about a rich man who took a poor man’s only lamb, waits for the king’s fury to reach its height, and then says four words: “Thou art the man.” Each of the three stories in this book is told first as a story, with proper care for its text, its history and its scholarship. Then it is allowed to turn round on the page and look at you. At the end of every chapter a short section called ‘The Fable Looks Back’ does exactly that, asking its questions of the one person every profession has learned to leave out of its findings, which is the person doing the reading.


The most important fact about the second fable is not in the tale, and it is the first piece of evidence in the book. In the spring of 1837 the third little booklet of Hans Christian Andersen’s Fairy Tales Told for Children was already at the printer in Copenhagen, and in the version sitting there, there was no child. The story ended with the Emperor resolving to wear his splendid suit at every procession, and with the whole town talking about his magnificent new clothes. The fiction was never broken. On the twenty-fifth of March Andersen wrote in some haste to his friend and patron Edvard Collin, asked for that ending to be erased entirely, and supplied the one we know: the child, the father, the whisper, the crowd’s cry, the Emperor’s shiver and the procession that goes on. His only stated reason was that it gave the whole a more satirical appearance.


Sit with that for a moment. The first draft of the most famous fable about collective self-deception ever written ended in total, successful and permanent collective self-deception. The child who sees was an afterthought, even for the man who imagined the child; and I say ‘the child’ deliberately, because Andersen’s Danish gives the child no sex, and in Andersen the child never laughs. Clarity arrived late, even for the author. That is the human condition in a sentence. We do not begin by seeing. We begin by being dressed, and by learning to praise the dressing, and by talking about it all over town. The child who says what everybody can see is never the first draft. The child is always a revision.


Why three fables, and why these? Because human beings have three ways of meeting a threat to their worth, and Karen Horney named them in 1945: moving towards others, in compliance; moving against them, in aggression; and moving away from them, into detachment. Andersen’s courtiers move towards, praising whatever they are told to praise. The gangs of the West Side move against. Grenouille moves away, seven years into a cave on a mountain, and then comes back down against the world with a vengeance. The Buddhist Fire Sermon counts the same three as the fires of greed, hatred and delusion, and Pascal counted three orders of reality and set love above the other two. I enter those rhymes on the Inferential ledger, which is where a bridge between literatures belongs until somebody tests it; but when traditions so far apart all count to three, and three stories line up beside their counting, the number begins to look less like an accident and more like an address.


The fables also show three different ways in which perception is captured. In Andersen, fear captures what people dare to say they see. In Süskind, desire captures what people actually feel they see. And on the playground, a young woman with less information, less status and less time than anybody else in her story recovers her sovereignty inside a field that has spent two acts making violence inevitable. One fable shows a single man, one a whole court, one two tribes of children. One is the climb, one the procession, one the crossing. Put them side by side and they draw a single road, and the road, I am sorry to tell you, is yours.


The Right-Hand Path, the Pen and the Mind That Cannot See Itself

The book’s account of the human condition begins in the nursery, with a contract that nobody ever signs. It is never written down. It is slipped under the nursery door in the ordinary weather of family life, and it says something like this: when you do the right thing, you will be brought close; when you fail, or cry, or are angry, or are merely ordinary, you will be held at a distance. I call the place where a child meets that contract the ‘First Fork’, and the decision she makes there the ‘Choiceless Choice’, because a child who must choose between being held and holding her own pen will always choose to be held. So the pen is surrendered, and with it the right to say what is happening, the right to interpret it, the right to narrate her own life and, in the end, the right to answer the question of who is doing the willing. The adult who grows from that child will spend a lifetime living inside stories written by other people, and will call them a career, a marriage, a reputation and a character.


The road that leaves the fork I call the ‘Right-Hand Path’: the long, decorated, exhausting climb of a human being who learned, very early, that existence must be earned. Along it the sacred sequence of a life, BE then DO then HAVE, is quietly run backwards, so that worth is moved to the end of the sentence, where it can only ever be a prize: when I have enough, I will be able to do what I want, and then, at last, I will be allowed to be. At the top stands what I call the ‘Temple of Emotional Anaesthesia’, which is less a metaphor for a workplace than a specification for one, and you can check it against your own in an afternoon, preferably one you have taken off. Attendance is a virtue. Exhaustion is evidence of commitment. Emotion in a practitioner is a lapse in professionalism. And the hierarchy corresponds, with uncanny precision, to how completely each person has finished being anaesthetised. The Temple’s guardian is the Panopticon, Jeremy Bentham’s prison whose inmates police themselves because they can never be sure they are not being watched; except that the original panopticon was built in the nursery out of a parent’s face, and by adulthood the inspector has a permanent office in one’s own head. In time the Temple becomes a Prison whose door is not locked but forgotten, and burnout, in this reading, is not the end of the world. It is the moment the anaesthetic wears off. Nobody on this road, I should say at once, is guilty of anything except being human. The adaptation was intelligent, the armour was protective, and the climb took a child’s whole courage and an adult’s whole life.


Then comes the irony at the centre of the book. The human condition has plagued what I call the ‘intellectual ego-mind’, and what most of us simply call the mind, for millennia, and it is precisely that mind which has stopped us from seeing how to heal it. It is magnificent at WHAT and HOW. It can sequence a genome and land a probe on a comet. It is almost entirely silent about WHO is looking, from WHERE, and for WHY, and so it has examined the human being from every angle except the one it occupies. Some of the credit belongs to a young Frenchman who, in the autumn of 1619, spent whole days alone in a stove-heated room in southern Germany and found the one thing his doubt could not dissolve, which was the doubter. René Descartes concluded that he was a thing whose whole essence was to think, which had need of no place, and Western intellectual life has been living in that warm room ever since. When Elisabeth of Bohemia, a princess of twenty-four, asked him in 1643 how such a thing could move an arm, he conceded, to his great credit, that the union of soul and body is learned not by meditation but by life and ordinary conversation. The professions trained the rest of us out of that concession. I call the training ‘somatic decapitation’, and the book lets the Earth Hand correct the popular version of the story as it goes: stress does not trap anybody in the prefrontal cortex, it tends to eject them from it, and the old three-storey brain with a reptile in the basement is a diagram no neuroscientist would now draw. What the evidence does allow is enough. A culturally rewarded habit of narrating oneself, a weakened sense of the body’s interior and a practised suppression of what that interior reports feel, from the inside, exactly like being trapped in the head. I call the result ‘Cognitive Enclosure’, and beneath it lies the ‘Enclosure of the Knower’, in which the very self doing the knowing is fused with fear, role, reward and the worldview of an institution. The ultimate enclosure is not ignorance. It is the enclosure of the knower.


The institutions have a partner condition, which I call the ‘jurisdictional quarantine of causation’. Professions live by holding jurisdiction over classes of problem, and the causes of human suffering do not respect jurisdictions. A woman of fifty may be treated for her blood pressure, her depression, her drinking and her marriage, and finally seen by a coroner, each service owning one segment of a single causal arc that began, very often, in a childhood nobody was paid to look at, as the original Adverse Childhood Experiences study showed in some nine and a half thousand adults (Relationship of childhood abuse and household dysfunction to many of the leading causes of death in adults: the Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACE) Study, Marks, American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 1998). The book’s answer is a ‘Council of Disciplines’, in which medicine, psychology, neuroscience, philosophy, sociology, law, systems theory, literature and the contemplative traditions are convened as partial witnesses to one human life: each bringing its spotlight, each asked what its spotlight cannot see, each speaking and none ruling. That is all I mean by trans-paradigmatic. The human being cannot be reduced to the silos of the academy or the ontological arrogance of the professions, and a book that tried would only add another wing to the Temple.


And so to the reversal on which the whole book turns. Kipling gave us six honest serving-men, What and Why and When and How and Where and Who, and the professions have ranked them in a fixed order: WHAT, then HOW, then perhaps WHY, with WHERE and WHO assumed and never examined. The book turns the order round, to WHO, then WHERE, then WHY, and only then HOW and WHAT. I call this the ‘Interrogative Reversal’, and its grammar is the spine of everything: BEing precedes location, which precedes meaning. Before you can know why, you must know where you are standing when you ask, and before you can know where, you must know who is asking. That is why I owe an apology, and a debt, to two men I admire, Viktor Frankl and Simon Sinek, who taught a generation to start with why. With respect, and with gratitude: sorry, gentlemen, but BEing and location come first. Meaning is real and it matters enormously, but it is the wake of the boat and not its engine. The engine is the location of the knower, and the knower can move. The laboratory has caught a glimpse of it. People reason more wisely about a friend’s troubles than about their own, and the difference disappears when they consider their own troubles from a distance, as an observer would (Exploring Solomon’s paradox: self-distancing eliminates the self-other asymmetry in wise reasoning about close relationships in younger and older adults, Kross, Psychological Science, 2014). Nothing about the facts changes. Only the location of the knower moves. From there the book’s sequence can be said in five short sentences, which I would happily see carved over the door of every hospital, set of chambers and university in the land: Consciousness sees the prison. Clarity sees the door. The Pivot touches the handle. Agency opens it. The Crossing begins with the first step outside.


Three Fables, One Human Condition

The middle of the book walks one road three times, with three travellers, and each of them stops at a different station.


Perfume: He Does Not Die Because His Perfume Failed

“He does not die because his perfume failed. He dies because it worked.”

Part Two climbs the Right-Hand Path with the one man in literature who obtained, completely, the thing he thought he lacked. Jean-Baptiste Grenouille is handed back by his wet nurse because there is nothing in him to smell, frightens the priest who receives him by seeming to sniff him out, and is raised by a woman whose impeccable fairness is the shape that anaesthesia takes. Read as a story, it is grotesque. Read as a fable, it is the First Fork in its purest form: a child refused before he could even be priced, who decides, so Süskind’s narrator tells us, against love and for life, and survives like a tick, small and grey and needing nothing, waiting. From there the novel is the Right-Hand Path climbed with terrible efficiency: the girl with the plums, whom he kills in order to possess what comes off her skin; the apprenticeship in which his genius writes formulas that make another man’s name; seven years alone in a cave on a mountain, in the most perfect Temple of Emotional Anaesthesia ever built, ruling an inner empire that nobody else lives in; and the night of the fog, when he discovers that he has no odour of his own and treats that door as a technical deficiency. Then he learns the most terrible thing in the novel, which is that he does not need to be lovable, only legible as lovable. In Grasse he builds a wardrobe of scents, one for being overlooked, one for arousing pity, one for being left alone, and that wardrobe is the most exact description I know of what I call ‘roles-not-Souls’. The question is never whether one wears scents. The question is whether there is anybody wearing them.


Grasse is also where the book sets out the ‘prestige-as-survival economy’, the social market in which ‘imitation love’ trades, and in which standing is felt in the body as a matter of life and death, because in the small groups in which our species evolved it very nearly was. Antoine Richis loves his daughter Laure and invests in her in the same gesture, and the Earth Hand can tell those two things apart in real families: a study that followed 565 Dutch children and their parents found that parental overvaluation, the belief that one’s child is more special and more deserving than other children, predicted narcissism, while parental warmth predicted healthy self-esteem (Origins of narcissism in children, Bushman, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2015). Imitation love, as I define it, is feeling engineered without any real encounter, and Grenouille engineers it on a scale nobody has attempted. On the scaffold, the crowd that came to see him broken falls in love with him, and the book insists on a distinction that matters more than almost any other: the crowd’s love is not fake. Imitation love is not necessarily an imitation feeling. What is counterfeit is the relationship beneath the feeling. At the summit of the Right-Hand Path, adored by everybody, Grenouille feels nothing but disgust and then hatred, because he understands that what they love is not him. He walks back to Paris, to the Innocents where he was born, and is torn to pieces by people who believe, afterwards, that for once in their lives they acted out of love. He does not die because his perfume failed. He dies because it worked.

“The cry was not an instinctive cry for sympathy and love. It was a considered cry, almost a mature one, by which the newborn decided against love and nevertheless for life; for in his circumstances the second was possible only without the first.”

Two mechanisms leave Grasse with the reader and travel through the rest of the book. The first is the ‘dose–response inversion’: adoration is the only arrangement in which increasing the dose decreases the amount received, because it is addressed to the shape that was built to keep the person out. The second is the Pivot declined. On the scaffold Grenouille saw the prison and saw the door as clearly as anybody in the book sees anything, and he did not touch the handle.


“For the first time in their lives, they had done something out of love.”
Figure 1. Imitation Love: Adored by Thousands, Met by No One. Every eye in the square is closed but one.
Figure 1. Imitation Love: Adored by Thousands, Met by No One. Every eye in the square is closed but one.

The Emperor’s New Clothes: Idolatry and the Twin Facing the Other Way

Part Three reads Andersen twice: once as the comic satire on vanity that everybody remembers, and once as a complete model of the Temple and its Panopticon at the scale of a state. Of any other ruler, Andersen tells us, one would say that he was in council; of this one, that he is in his wardrobe. And the cloth he buys tests something very particular. In the medieval Spanish tale that lies behind Andersen’s, an invisible cloth tested legitimacy of birth; Andersen made it test fitness for office, and with that single change the fable became ours. Nobody in a modern institution fears being exposed as illegitimate. Everybody fears being exposed as unfit. The courtiers are not hypocrites. They are frightened men inside what I call an epistemic incentive structure, which rewards them for believing what is false and punishes them for perceiving what is true, and the book defines what they are doing with some care. Idolatry is the conversion of a human being into a function, and of the function into a commodity that anybody may carry. The Emperor trades the garments that keep a body warm for a costume that cannot keep anybody warm because it does not exist, which is the whole economy of imitation love in a single gesture.

“The Emperor was vexed, for he knew that the people were right; but he thought the procession must go on now! And the lords of the bedchamber took greater pains than ever, to appear holding up a train, although, in reality, there was no train to hold.”

Then the book turns to something that is not in Andersen’s story and is present on every page of it: idolatry’s twin, which is scapegoating, the same operation facing the other way. The interior is removed, a function is installed, and the crowd relates to the function, whether by adoring it or by expelling it. Its clearest modern case in Britain is the prosecution of hundreds of subpostmasters on the evidence of a computer system that was presumed unable to be wrong, until the High Court found that it could be (Bates and others v Post Office Ltd (No 6) “Horizon Issues”, Fraser, High Court of England and Wales, 2019). And then the four moves of Andersen’s ending, the child, the father, the whisper and the crowd, yield the most practical teaching in the book. “But the Emperor has nothing at all on!” says a little child, in the old public-domain translation, and the sentence would have died in the air if the father had not vouched for it. In Solomon Asch’s conformity experiments, a single honest ally in the room cut conformity by around three-quarters. You do not have to be the child. You can almost always be the second voice: the father in the street who says listen, and who builds, in a single sentence, what I call the ‘Sanctuary of Witness’, a Reverse Panopticon in which a person is fully seen and not judged.

“‘But the Emperor has nothing at all on!’ said a little child.” 

And then the four seconds. “The Emperor was vexed, for he knew that the people were right; but he thought the procession must go on now!” Andersen’s Danish is plainer and more bodily: something crept through the Emperor, for it seemed to him that they were right. The body knows first. In those four seconds the door stands open, and he holds out, and the train that is not there is carried more proudly than ever. The Pivot is declined a second time. So the book offers a third ending of its own, clearly labelled as mine and not Andersen’s, in which the Emperor looks down at his bare feet on the cobbles, and laughs.


Figure 2. Idolatry: Prestige Replaces Perception. Everything the office can carry is real. None of it covers him.
Figure 2. Idolatry: Prestige Replaces Perception. Everything the office can carry is real. None of it covers him.

West Side Story: Ave Maria at the Gun

Part Four walks from Verona to the Upper West Side. Romeo and Juliet supplies the anatomy of an inherited feud, a letter stopped at a door by the officers of public health, and an ending in golden statues set up in a public place. West Side Story follows the play almost scene for scene until the last, and then does something the tragedy never did. The book reads the two gangs as a shared Temple of Emotional Anaesthesia, which offers its boys sanctuary from a wound that once had no language, and turns the sanctuary into a prison by requiring an enemy. The Earth Hand is unsentimental here. Violence arises far more often from threatened egotism than from low self-esteem (Relation of threatened egotism to violence and aggression: the dark side of high self-esteem, Boden, Psychological Review, 1996), and cultures of honour can be measured in the bloodstream: insulted young men raised in one show sharper rises in cortisol and testosterone (Insult, aggression, and the southern culture of honor: an “experimental ethnography”, Schwarz, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1996). The Jets themselves, in ‘Gee, Officer Krupke’, the most merciless comic number in the show, demonstrate to a policeman how the professional vocabulary of wounds can be turned into an alibi. And Anita, arriving at the drugstore with a message that might have saved a life, meets contempt, and passes it on as the lie that kills.

“You all killed him! And my brother, too. And Riff. Not with bullets and guns! With hate! Well I can kill now too, because now I have hate!”

Then the playground. Tony has been shot. Maria holds his body and the gun, with the grief of a brother and of a lover, the rage, the weapon and the targets all in front of her, at the point of maximum causal permission for repetition. She does not fire. What I call the ‘Maria Protocol’ is not a technique but a sequence of recognitions: the inherited script seen as a script; the shadow owned rather than projected, because she says aloud, in front of everybody, that she could kill now, because now she hates too; the weapon held, felt and not used; the body lifted together; and the next act authored rather than inherited. She does not stop feeling the hate. It loses its monopoly. Fear, grief and hate keep their seats in the parliament; what changes is who casts the deciding ballot. And then there is the silence, which I believe is the deepest teaching in the whole story. In an art form whose founding convention is that when feeling exceeds speech you sing, at the moment of greatest feeling in the whole work, Maria does not sing. She speaks. Bernstein wanted an aria there; Sondheim, by his own later account, persuaded him that she should simply speak, and no aria for the scene was ever written (Stephen Sondheim on Look, I Made a Hat, Sondheim, BroadwayWorld, 2011). I read that silence, on the Metaphysical ledger, as the moment at which representation gives way to action. Maria does not need to sing the next world into existence. She has to author the next available act.


Beside the scene stands the book’s brightest guardrail, because ideas strong enough to heal are strong enough to be misused. The Pivot is the refusal to pass the wound on. It is never a vow to keep receiving it. Not firing is not the same as not leaving. And then boys from both gangs come forward and lift the body, and the procession that follows is the first in the story that belongs to everyone. Verona’s ending is gold, and the West Side’s ending is weight: one of them is admired, and the other is carried. Bernstein lets the melody of hope rise in the strings while the restless tritone sounds beneath it, unresolved, and the music keeps the book honest. The Crossing does not abolish the friction of the world. It changes who is walking through it.


Figure 3. The Inherited Script: Two Tribes, One Wound. One grief, poured into two sets of clothes.
Figure 3. The Inherited Script: Two Tribes, One Wound. One grief, poured into two sets of clothes.

How It Heals: The Pivot, Re-Collection and the Field on a Tuesday

If the three fables were only a diagnosis, this would be a clever and rather depressing book, and the world already has enough of those. Part Five is the way out, and it begins with a question. There is a question that circulates in coaching rooms, sermons and the better kind of greetings card: what would love do now? It is a beautiful question, and for most of the people I work with it is also a trap, because the frightened overachiever hears it from inside the old court and answers it in the only grammar that court understands. Love, they conclude, would work harder, stay later, say yes to the third committee and absorb the blow. So the book never asks the question bare. It asks what I call the ‘Paradoxical Query’: who would I need to BE to know the answer to the question: what would love do now? It is not a moral calculator. It relocates the chooser before the choice, so that the next act is authored from somewhere other than the old, frightened monopoly. That relocation is the ‘Pivot’, Step Zero of a hundred, and in the chart I keep for it, it is given four words: the chooser becomes visible. Enlightenment, in this grammar, is not choosing better outcomes. It is choosing who is choosing.


Chapter Twenty-One begins where most of the people who come to me begin, at the bottom of the Right-Hand Path, in the condition we call burnout when it happens to a professional and rock bottom when it happens to a drunk, and it argues that rock bottom is not the floor of the house. It is a door. At the bottom there are two doors: death, whether literal or the living death of tightened armour, and the Pivot. William Miller and Janet C’de Baca, studying people whose lives had changed suddenly and lastingly, found their values turned upside down, with wealth, achievement and the regard of others falling away and quieter goods rising in their place (Quantum Change: When Epiphanies and Sudden Insights Transform Ordinary Lives, Miller, Guilford Press, 2001), and Oscar Wilde, writing from a prison cell, had already found the sentence for it: “Where there is sorrow there is holy ground.” But the Earth Hand keeps the chapter honest. The evidence that burnout becomes growth is thin. The phoenix is a possibility to be cultivated, never a promise to be demanded, and rock bottom must never become an entrance requirement. There is a door on every floor of the house, and the Pivot can be met on the stairs.


What follows the Pivot I call ‘Re-Collection’, with a hyphen, because it means three things at once: remembering; gathering again what was scattered; and discovering that the debt being collected was never owed. It is not the construction of a new identity, which is the mistake almost everybody makes on first hearing it, and the mistake that turns transformation into one more acquisition. It restores order, so that worth returns to the front of the sentence as a premise rather than a prize, and the sacred sequence runs forwards again: BE, then DO, then HAVE. The Earth Hand’s work on the reconsolidation of memory suggests, with honest caveats that the book states plainly, that a memory recalled in a new context can be stored again in a changed form (Fear memories require protein synthesis in the amygdala for reconsolidation after retrieval, LeDoux, Nature, 2000). The event is not erased. The verdict it carries can change. If there is one sentence the whole book has been earning, it is this: the facts stay still while the knower moves. Exiled parts do not return to a court. They return to a home. And the child who surrendered the pen at the First Fork may have been holding it all along, waiting for the adult to come back and hold it with her.


Chapter Twenty-Three then sets out a genealogy of the wills that have driven Western psychology, from Schopenhauer’s will to live, through the will to power and the will to pleasure, to Frankl’s will to meaning, and ends with the Will to Love, which gives my wider work its name. The Will to Power is combustion: it runs by burning the person as fuel. The Will to Love is fusion: it gives light from within, and the one who runs on it is not the fuel. The book’s Latin spine, its counter-sentence to Descartes, belongs here: Sum, ergo diligo. I am, therefore I love. And Chapter Twenty-Four asks what the ‘Field of BEing’ looks like on an ordinary Tuesday, and answers that from outside it often looks exactly like the Temple. The surgeon is still operating, the barrister is still in court, and the packed lunches are still being made. What has changed is invisible to an auditor with a clipboard, and it is everything: the work is no longer a referendum on whether the worker is enough. The chapter gives the Seven R’s of everyday practice, Reality, Relax, Release, Relinquish resistance, Return to presence, Respond and Rise; a worked example of the Paradoxical Query on the morning a colleague steals your credit; and evidence that is encouraging without being miraculous, such as the randomised trial in which eight weeks of Mindful Self-Compassion left people more self-compassionate, and less depressed, anxious and stressed, than people still waiting for the same programme (A pilot study and randomized controlled trial of the mindful self-compassion program, Germer, Journal of Clinical Psychology, 2013). The Field turns out to be not a place at all, but the felt condition of love, joy, peace, and alignment, which is the signature of Truth: the Interrogative Reversal completed, with WHO answered first, WHERE next, and WHY arriving without being looked for. The twenty-nine tools of the Crossing are in the book too, set out at the end of Part Four in a chart of their own, under one strict rule: the tools come after the chooser. Picked up before the chooser appears, they are seized by the old regent and turned into performance, twenty-nine new commandments of King Burnout.


The Epilogue then does something I am rather proud of, which is to warn the reader against the book. Andersen’s honest old minister left the looms as the best-informed man in the kingdom on the subject of a cloth that did not exist, and a reader can leave these pages with a magnificent description of the colours and patterns of their own condition, and wear it in every procession for the rest of their life. Insight is the most sophisticated anaesthetic in the building. A prison described is still a prison. So the Epilogue sets out three doors and no keys: Kafka’s man from the country, who waits his whole life before a door in the Law that was meant only for him; Holman Hunt’s door with no handle on the outside, because the closed door, he explained, was “the obstinately shut mind”; and the three doors of the three fables, none of them locked. I have drawn those three, because a sentence can be read past and a picture has to be looked at, and they come in order: first the joining, then the rejoicing, then the trust.


Figure 4. What Could Not Be Distilled. The one essence he never captured was sitting beside him.
Figure 4. What Could Not Be Distilled. The one essence he never captured was sitting beside him.
Figure 5. The Day the Emperor Laughed. It cost him nothing he needed. Only the shape.
Figure 5. The Day the Emperor Laughed. It cost him nothing he needed. Only the shape.
Figure 6. The Next Sentence. The past supplies the gun. It does not get the next sentence.
Figure 6. The Next Sentence. The past supplies the gun. It does not get the next sentence.

In each picture a grown person turns round and finds the child who has been holding the pen all along. The perfumer’s cave has become a workshop full of daylight, with the flacons still on the shelves, because Re-Collection does not burn the workshop or renounce the gift, and his hand rests around a little girl’s on the pen without taking it from her. The Emperor laughs, and the court laughs with him rather than at him, and the difference between those two prepositions is the difference between a scapegoat and a human being; he is still crowned, because the Pivot does not require him to abdicate, only that the clothes stop standing in for the man. And in a cathedral with its roof taken off, open to the valley and the sky, a woman wearing the shawl that Maria let fall on the playground rests her cheek on her hand and watches a girl write, with her own hands nowhere near the pen. Set the three side by side and the locksmith’s shop goes quiet: there is not a key among them. The handle, in every case, was on the inside, and the door opens towards you.


How the Book Is Built: Two Hands, Four Ledgers and a Quarantine

A book that accuses the professions of presenting their inferences as findings had better not do it itself, so this house has been built with its wiring on the outside. Everything in it is held with two hands. The Earth Hand is the hand of disciplined contact with what can be observed, measured, dated and checked: the attachment research, the cohort studies, the manuscript in the Royal Danish Library, the chapter and page of a novel. The Sky Hand holds what cannot be measured without being destroyed: consciousness, meaning, purpose, BEing and Truth. I hold the two apart on purpose and leave the seam between them visible, because evidence without vision is a very well-lit room with no windows, and vision without evidence is a window with nothing behind it. So every claim is entered in one of four ledgers, named on the page where the claim is made: the Empirical, which you are asked to check; the Inferential, which you are asked to weigh; the Normative, which you are asked to argue with; and the Metaphysical, which you may take or leave, so long as you know which you are doing. Nothing on the Empirical ledger depends on the Metaphysical one. At the back, an Afterword cross-audits the whole architecture across all four ledgers, claim by claim, with the strongest evidence for each, its strongest counter-witness and what would change my mind, and it records where the Earth Hand corrected me on the way. A book that praises the child who says the cloth is not there should be willing to show where its own cloth was thin.


The book also keeps a quarantine, and I am rather fond of it. Some of the most beautiful sentences in the literature of awakening were never written by the people to whom they are attributed, and a book that warns against worshipping what is not there has a duty not to quote what was never said. So before the journey begins it names what you will not find, and why. The famous sentence about a space between stimulus and response is not in Viktor Frankl’s published work. The line about making the unconscious conscious, lest you call it fate, is a modern condensation: the thought is Jung’s, the sentence is not. The letter in which Einstein supposedly told his daughter that love is the universal force is a twenty-first-century invention. The charming story that Andersen added his child because, as a little boy, he had been disappointed to find that King Frederik VI looked like an ordinary man has no primary source that I could find. And Andersen’s child, as I said, does not laugh; where a laugh appears in the book, it is mine, and it is marked as mine. Copyright gets the same courtesy. I quote no lyric of West Side Story at all, and describe instead what the songs do, their grammar, their placement and the music under them, which is where the evidence lives anyway. Süskind’s novel is paraphrased, with chapter and page given for every scene, so that you can read his words in his book. Andersen, Shakespeare and the other public-domain witnesses are quoted at whatever length the argument needs.


As for the rooms: the book opens with a two-page description, a Contents page and an Executive Summary called ‘The Whole Book in One Sitting’, written for the surgeon between lists, the barrister between hearings and the person lying awake at three in the morning who cannot yet face two hundred pages but might manage fifteen. An executive summary is the Right-Hand Path’s favourite literary form, since it promises the WHAT and the HOW of a book without the inconvenience of being changed by it. I wrote one anyway, because a map is a kindness to a traveller, so long as nobody mistakes it for the walk. Then come a short note on how to read the book, a Prologue that tells all three stories in a few pages, and five Parts and twenty-four chapters that follow the oldest clinical outline we possess, the Four Noble Truths: the shape of the path, the climb, the procession, the crossing and the field. Every chapter ends with ‘The Fable Looks Back’. Twenty-two charts carry the architecture for readers who think in tables, among them ‘One Road, Three Travellers’, which walks Grenouille, the Emperor and Maria side by side through every station of the road. Six pictures carry it for readers who think in images, and the cover is read in the Epilogue as a fourth fable. Then the Afterword, a Note on Quotations, Permissions and Sources, and the References. Read it in order once, if you can, because the order is part of the argument. After that it is a house with several doors, and you may come and go as you please.


Who It Is For, and Where It Found Me

I wrote the book for the high achiever who has reached the top of the building and found it only one storey tall; for the clinician, the lawyer, the leader and the teacher who were trained to switch off the part of themselves that feels; for anybody who has praised a garment they could not see in order to keep their place, or been loved for their scent and never for themselves; and for anybody who has stood at a moment of recognition with a weapon in their hand, a sentence, a vote, an email sitting in the drafts folder, and wondered which way to turn. It is written for people who are very good at reading and who have read their way into a corner, which is why it does not simply argue. Such readers win the argument and lose the point. So it shows before it tells, tells honestly enough to be trusted, and then steps back far enough for the reader to do the one thing no book can do for anybody, which is turn.


It is not a programme, and I am not a guru seeking followers. The book is closer to a flight manual for an aircraft you have been flying blind for years. You do not have to believe a word of it. You have to try one thing, once, badly, at the moment the book asks you to, and then notice what moves.


It would also be a strange book about the knower if its author hid behind a screen of clinical detachment, so I am in it, strictly in the register of testimony rather than proof. When I was seven I came last in a race at my school sports day. My mother was furious. She turned on her red heels, walked towards the car, and left. What my nervous system appears to have encoded, far more durably than the sting of losing, was what the losing meant: love leaves when you lose. I was bad at running and exceptionally good at studying, so I changed tracks, as intelligent children do. Books. Cambridge. Medicine. Surgery. And, many years later, five marathons, run with an urgency I could not have explained to you if you had asked. The facts of that afternoon never changed. What changed, one day, was the place I was seeing them from, and the sentence I found at the end of all that running is the one I would carve if I were allowed a single stone: “I could never win that race. I could only stop running it.” Or, in two prepositions that contain most of the book: “I was running for love. I was never running in love.” None of this is a prosecution of my mother, who was doing what she had been taught by people who had been taught it by others, in a long line of frightened adults running back further than anybody can trace.


I met the hinge itself not in a library but in a hospital car park, at two o’clock in the morning, in a dark suit, with my hands on the steering wheel and a key that would not turn. The book tells that story properly, in Part Five, so I will say only this about it here: nothing in the car park changed. The ceiling did. And the book ends where it began, on that school field, with the boy who came last and the woman in red heels walking towards the car. Nothing there has changed, and everything has, because of who is standing beside the boy now.


A word of care, because it matters more than anything I have said about architecture. The book talks about burnout, rock bottom and the long dark of the Temple with a certain wild cheerfulness, because I have seen what lies on the other side of them. But it is educational and reflective, and it is not a substitute for individual clinical care, and nobody should wait to hit bottom before asking for help. If you are in immediate distress, please do not wait to finish this article, or the book. In the United Kingdom you can call the Samaritans free on 116 123, at any hour; elsewhere, your local emergency number or a trusted doctor is the right first door.


The Next Sentence: Where to Find the Book

So here are the practical details, delivered with the brevity a blank page deserves. Three Fables, One Human Condition, and How to Heal It: Perfume, The Emperor’s New Clothes and West Side Story is published today in its first edition, publication version 1.0, as an eBook from Transformative Life Coach, and you will find it among my eBooks. It runs to 273 pages, a Prologue, five Parts and twenty-four chapters, an Epilogue, an Afterword, a Note on Quotations, Permissions and Sources, and the References, with an Executive Summary at the front for the impatient, twenty-two charts for the cartographers and six pictures for everybody else. Its permanent address is its DOI, https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24368830, and if you would like to cite it, it should be cited as: Branford, O. (2026). Three Fables, One Human Condition, and How to Heal It: Perfume, The Emperor’s New Clothes and West Side Story. Transformative Life Coach. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24368830.


How to buy the book

Buy 'Three Fables, One Human Condition, and How to Heal It: Perfume, The Emperor’s New Clothes and West Side Story':



It stands on its own, so you can walk straight in from the street without having read anything else of mine; if you have, you will find the furniture familiar. It sits beside The Pivot, published earlier this month, which slows a single moment of this road, the hinge, down to walking pace. This book draws the whole road, from the First Fork to the Field, and gives it three travellers. Both belong to the wider work that takes its name from the Will to Love, and both can be entered from any door of it: the Map Room, Start Here for the Way Back to You, An Invitation to the Real You, my articles, the Audio Library and Podcasts and my videos.


I owe thanks that a blog cannot properly hold, and the deepest go, as always, to the people who have sat with me at the top of their buildings and told me the truth about the view. Their stories remain theirs. If you read the book, I would love to hear where it found you: which fable turned round first, where you discovered that you were the Emperor, which picture you kept going back to, and what you would like to say to the Afterword. Write to me at hello@transformativelifecoach.co.uk, argue with me, take the book to your reading group, or leave it on the bedside table until the evening it is needed. It will wait. Fables are patient.


The cover shows a woman and the girl she once was, holding one pen together at a threshold, with three fables behind them and a blank page in front. The page is not blank because the story has ended. It is blank because, for the first time, its author is free to begin. The past supplies the gun, the grief, the hatred and the available script. It does not get automatic authorship of the next sentence. That sentence is yours, and so is the pen, and so, it turns out, was the door, which was never locked.



Buy 'Three Fables, One Human Condition, and How to Heal It: Perfume, The Emperor’s New Clothes and West Side Story':



Dr Olivier Branford MBBS, MA(Cantab), PhD


References

A pilot study and randomized controlled trial of the mindful self-compassion program. Neff, K.D.; Germer, C.K. Journal of Clinical Psychology 2013; 69(1):28–44. [Accessed 19 November 2026].

Andersen’s Fairy Tales. Andersen, H.C. Anonymous nineteenth-century English translation. Project Gutenberg eBook #1597. [Accessed 19 November 2026].

Bates and others v Post Office Ltd (No 6) “Horizon Issues”. Fraser, P. [2019] EWHC 3408 (QB). High Court of England and Wales; 2019. [Accessed 19 November 2026].

De Profundis. Wilde, O. Methuen; 1905.

Eventyr, fortalte for Børn. Tredie Hefte. Andersen, H.C. C. A. Reitzel; 1837.

Exploring Solomon’s paradox: self-distancing eliminates the self-other asymmetry in wise reasoning about close relationships in younger and older adults. Grossmann, I.; Kross, E. Psychological Science 2014; 25(8):1571–1580. [Accessed 19 November 2026].

Fear memories require protein synthesis in the amygdala for reconsolidation after retrieval. Nader, K.; Schafe, G.E.; et al. Nature 2000; 406(6797):722–726. [Accessed 19 November 2026].

H. C. Andersen’s letters: Andersen to Edvard Collin, 25 March 1837. Andersen, H.C. H. C. Andersen Centre, University of Southern Denmark. [Accessed 19 November 2026].

Insult, aggression, and the southern culture of honor: an “experimental ethnography”. Cohen, D.; Nisbett, R.E.; et al. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1996; 70(5):945–960. [Accessed 19 November 2026].

Just So Stories for Little Children. Kipling, R. Macmillan; 1902.

Origins of narcissism in children. Brummelman, E.; Thomaes, S.; et al. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2015; 112(12):3659–3662. [Accessed 19 November 2026].

Perfume: The Story of a Murderer. Süskind, P. Trans. Woods, J.E. Vintage; 2001.

Quantum Change: When Epiphanies and Sudden Insights Transform Ordinary Lives. Miller, W.R.; C’de Baca, J. Guilford Press; 2001.

Relation of threatened egotism to violence and aggression: the dark side of high self-esteem. Baumeister, R.F.; Smart, L.; et al. Psychological Review 1996; 103(1):5–33. [Accessed 19 November 2026].

Relationship of childhood abuse and household dysfunction to many of the leading causes of death in adults: the Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACE) Study. Felitti, V.J.; Anda, R.F.; et al. American Journal of Preventive Medicine 1998; 14(4):245–258. [Accessed 19 November 2026].

Stephen Sondheim on Look, I Made a Hat. Sondheim, S. BroadwayWorld 2011. [Accessed 19 November 2026].

West Side Story. Laurents, A.; Bernstein, L.; et al. Random House; 1958.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page